Four Themes of ULI’s Butcher Forum on Multifamily Housing

More than 30 of the nation’s leading multifamily developers, owners, and capital providers gathered in May to discuss issues facing the industry at the 2nd annual ULI/Carolyn and Preston Butcher Forum on Multifamily Housing in Houston, Texas, with four key themes emerging.

800_multifamily

(Edgaras Maselskis/Unsplash.com)

In the most recent data from the U.S. Commerce Department, multifamily construction starts were up 29.4 percent month over month in June. Well into the current cycle, multifamily development remains remarkably strong by almost any measure.

More than 30 of the nation’s leading multifamily developers, owners, and capital providers gathered in Houston last May to discuss issues facing the industry at the second annual ULI/Carolyn and Preston Butcher Forum on Multifamily Housing, with four key themes emerging:

Capital. Participants discussed a multifamily cycle that is the strongest in a generation and that shows little signs of slowing. Apartment sales in early 2015 exceeded the pre–Great Recession peak. Last year saw the most rental starts since 1987 (although also the fewest condominium starts since the early 1970s). Buyers are paying record prices, especially for urban high-rise product. A desire to own hard assets in supply-constrained markets is driving low cap rates in the 3 to 4 percent range, as private equity and other sources continue to raise large investment funds.

Demand. Participants discussed distinguishing characteristics of the younger and more affluent millennials: they are more likely than prior generations to decide where they want to live before securing a job and have less attachment to ownership—of homes, cars, consumer goods—than other groups, having come of age in the mobile technology–enabled “sharing economy.” Also noted: African Americans and Hispanics will drive much of future housing demand; and because they have much lower average incomes and net worth than whites, significant pressures for more affordable offerings will emerge.

Development. A major concern is labor costs, which are often exacerbated by a shortage of qualified contractors and requirements to pay prevailing union wages, among other factors. The out-of-pocket costs and time horizons associated with public approvals also are a major and in many markets escalating cost, especially for urban infill and mixed-use projects. According to participants’ experience, modular technologies have generally not delivered on their promise to achieve significant cost savings.

Leadership. Succession planning across the industry is a major challenge, and it needs to be addressed at all levels of the company, not just at the top. One approach is to evaluate all leadership staff on how well they are developing their successors. Culture must be a priority of leadership and emanate from the top, as one participant noted: “The one day you do not work on culture, you’ve got to spend two days fixing it.”

Stockton Williams is Executive Vice President of Content for ULI and Executive Director of the ULI Terwilliger Center for Housing. Mr. Williams has executive management responsibility for ULI’s member-driven program of research and analysis on housing and communities, real estate finance and investment, urban sustainability, development practice, and shaping cities and regions. He is most recently the co-author of the ULI publications The Economics of Inclusionary Development and Housing in the Evolving American Suburb. He is a frequent commentator on housing issues in the media and an advisor to local communities across the U.S. Before joining ULI in January 2015, Mr. Williams was Managing Principal of the Washington, D.C. office of HR&A Advisors. He also served as Senior Advisor in two Federal Cabinet agencies: the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the U.S. Department of Energy. He also been Senior Vice President and Chief Strategy Officer at Enterprise Community Partners; a Senior Advisor at Living Cities; a Senior Legislative and Policy Associate at the National Council of State Housing Agencies; and a developer of affordable housing. Mr. Williams is Chairman of the Board of Groundswell, a community solar organization serving low-income communities. He holds an M.S. from Columbia University and a B.A. from Princeton University.
Members Sign In
Don’t have an account yet? Sign up for a ULI guest account.
Members Get More

With a ULI membership, you’ll stay informed on the most important topics shaping the world of real estate with unlimited access to the award-winning Urban Land magazine.

Learn more about the benefits of membership
Already have an account?