Zipcar Ranks Top Vibrant, Efficient and Sustainable Cities

by Richard Florida

Text Size: A | A | A

March 6, 2012

  • FloridaCities_1_619
    San Francisco, California. Image courtesy of Flickr user Laughing Squid.

Earlier this week, Zipcar published its Future Metropolis Index. To develop the Index, the company teamed up with KRC Research to rank the top 36 most populated U.S. cities on five factors: sustainability, innovation, vibrancy, efficiency, and livability. See the top 10 cities and their corresponding scores below.

Here's how the cities break down in the five sub-categories:

  • In the innovation category, Atlanta, Pittsburgh, and Boston top the list.
  • Tuscon, Arizona, Portland, Oregon, and San Francisco are best in sustainability.                Cities_136x60_transparent
  • San Francisco, Seattle, and Washington, D.C., lead in vibrancy/creativity.
  • The most efficient cities are Washington, D.C., New York, and Boston.
  • For livability, El Paso, Texas, New York, and San Diego take top honors.

The study also found that Americans who live in metro areas are more optimistic about job opportunities than those living outside them.

The ranking and survey make sense for Zipcar, a company that provides car-sharing services to urban dwellers.

"The results of our Future Metropolis Index make a powerful statement about an urban renaissance that we see is clearly underway," Scott Griffith, chairman and CEO of Zipcar, said in a press release. "U.S. cities are growing and evolving and are more dynamic than ever before. This rebirth of our cities is being powered by technology and innovation coupled with smart urban policy which together work to enhance the lives of their residents."san francisco

1. San Francisco, California

Innovation: #7
Sustainability: #3
Vibrancy/Creativity: #1
Efficiency: #5 (tie)
Livability/Optimism: #4

Image courtesy of Flickr user Laughing Squidseattle space needle park


2. Seattle, Washington

Innovation: #8
Sustainability: #5 (tie)
Vibrancy/Creativity: #2 (tie)
Efficiency: #8
Livability/Optimism: #6 (tie)

Image courtesy of Flickr user mediafurywashington dc buildings

3. Washington, D.C.

Innovation: #4
Sustainability: #7 (tie)
Vibrancy/Creativity: #2 (tie)
Efficiency: #1
Livability/Optimism: #24 (tie)

Image courtesy of Flickr user dannyfowlerportland airtransit

4. Portland, Oregon

Innovation: #6
Sustainability: #2
Vibrancy/Creativity: #4
Efficiency: #11
Livability/Optimism: #10

Image courtesy of Flickr user C.M. Keinerboston downtown skyline

5. Boston, Massachusetts

Innovation: #3
Sustainability: #15
Vibrancy/Creativity: #9 (tie)
Efficiency: #3
Livability/Optimism: #6 (tie)

Image courtesy of Flickr user Werner Kunznew york city tower

6. New York City

Innovation: #15
Sustainability: #11
Vibrancy/Creativity: #7
Efficiency: #2
Livability/Optimism: #2

Image courtesy of Flickr user andrew c maceatlanta downtown

7. Atlanta, Georgia

Innovation: #1
Sustainability: #17 (tie)
Vibrancy/Creativity: #5 (tie)
Efficiency: #4
Livability/Optimism: #32

Image courtesy of Flickr user Stuck in Customsdenver downtown

8. Denver, Colorado

Innovation: #5
Sustainability: #14
Vibrancy/Creativity: #13
Efficiency: #13
Livability/Optimism: #6 (tie)

Image courtesy of Flickr user mattsantomarcopittsburgh downtown bridge

9. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Innovation: #2
Sustainability: #23 (tie)
Vibrancy/Creativity: #14 (tie)
Efficiency: #9
Livability/Optimism: #13 (tie)

Image courtesy of Flickr user jiuguangwaustin downtown skylinezip

10. (Tie) Austin, Texas

Innovation: #19
Sustainability: #5 (tie)
Vibrancy/Creativity: #9 (tie)
Efficiency: #18 (tie)
Livability/Optimism: #5

Image courtesy of Flickr user joshpattensan diego skyline

10. (Tie) San Diego, California

Innovation: #16 (tie)
Sustainability: #9
Vibrancy/Creativity: #8
Efficiency: #17
Livability/Optimism: #3

Image courtesy of Flickr user Nick Chill Photography

Reprinted with permission from The Atlantic Cities. Copyright 2012 by The Atlantic Monthly Group.

Want to join the conversation?


Log in or join ULI now.

Comments (4)

Mr. Peter M. Saucerman - Sacramento, CA wrote - on March 20, 2012 at 8:53 PM

Yes, I would suppose this informal, very UN-scientific poll to be heavily influenced by ZIP car being a San Francisco-based startup. "vibrancy" - it's a great word, but how exactly do you measure it?

Mr. Jerry W. Szatan - Chicago, IL wrote - on March 20, 2012 at 6:07 PM

El Paso, New York and San Diego make for an interesting group of top livability cities. They are not ones that I usually would think of together. I wonder what New York and El Paso in particular have in common that leads to this result?

Mr. David M. Strosberg - Chicago, IL wrote - on March 12, 2012 at 4:04 PM

I presume we don't acquire sufficient Zipcars in Chicago.

Ms. Deborah L. Brett - Plainsboro, NJ wrote - on March 12, 2012 at 2:37 PM

How could Chicago not appear on this list?

Specify objectionable content

Thank you for your comment.
Lutron_staticRetrofitRightWay_300x300

Advertisement